Joe Greniuk of Great Plains earned Second Team All-BEL honors.
| Player | Team | Position |
|---|---|---|
| Anton Castro | Blackhawks | Goaltender |
| Grant Martin | Kings | Goaltender |
| Kiron Morioka | Bruins | Goaltender |
| Matt Beaty | Bruins | Defense |
| Luke Gramer | North Stars | Defense |
| Luke Mittelstadt | Great Plains | Defense |
| Joe Greniuk | Great Plains | Defense |
| Tyler Chamberlain | Great Plains | Forward |
| Drew Holt | Sharks | Forward |
| Cade Ahrenholz | Kings | Forward |
| Hayden Helgeson | North Stars | Forward |
| Christian Galatz | North Stars | Forward |
| Jacob Jeanette | North Stars | Forward |
Christian Galatz impressed throughout the BEL season with his speed and stickhandling.