From start to finish, Mustangs Green owned the ice in the 2003 Orange final, breezing to a 5-0 win over Top Dog Hockey. 

Chayton Fischer led Mustangs Green with three assists in the win, with four different players marking the scoresheet in the goal column. Jacob Bahe scored twice for Mustangs Green, and Tyler Friedrichs, Jack Olsen, and Fischer all chipped in goals. Defensively, Alec Juenke earned the shutout for Mustangs Green, who topped the Wisconsin Jr. Stars 4-3 in the semifinals. 

Top Dog advanced to the championship game after a thrilling 5-4 win over the ASHCO Storm. 

Entering Sunday, Rapid Fire Group had yet to allow a goal, much less find themselves in any real danger through three pool play games. RFG's romp through the 2004 Orange Division was halted by a pair of losses, once in the morning and once in the afternoon, both to the champion Madison Capitols. 

Madison pulled away in the title game, scoring the game's final three goals en route to a 5-2 win. Aidan Lenz scored two goals and added an assist to lead the Capitols, with Cody Kempf, Isaac Nett, and Jonah Aegerter all chipping in single goals. Conner McClure scored both goals in the loss for RFG.  

Upper Midwest Superior held off a late charge from the Minnesota Freeze to escape with the championship in the 2005 Orange Division, with Jackson Potulny scoring the eventual game-winner to put the Warriors up 3-1 late in the third period. 

The Freeze took a 1-0 lead early in the first on a goal by John Finnegan, but UMW knotted the game at 1-1 minutes later. Lidstone Carter put UMW up 2-1 with a goal late in the first before Potulny's insurance goal in the third. Elliott Testa pulled the Freeze within one ay 3-2 with just 29 seconds remaining in regulation, but strong defense and goaltending by UMW prevailed in the game's final moments.  

Madison scored twice in the first, four times in the second, and for good measure scored again in the third period to cruise past Mustangs Green 7-1 in the 2006 Orange Division championship game. 

Both Vince Kalscheur and Michael Gruetzmacher scored twice in the win for the Capitols, with single goals coming from Wyatt Groth, Nico Quartuccio, and Jack Dahl. Connor Stokke closed out the game with the only goal for Mustangs Green.

Madison scored a win over the Bakken Oilers in their semifinal, while Mustangs Green took care of the Northern Wisconsin Blizzard in the other semifinal.